High Arctic Relocatees Outreach to Qaanaaq, Greenland November 6-11, 2010 (part 1)
Hunting and fishing were essential to their survival, and to their way of life, and there were no political or manmade boundaries between Ellesmere Island and Greenland at the time.
By the mid-1800s, still before the Canadian Confederation in 1867, Qillaq, a powerful Inuit leader and shaman, led some 60 Inuit from Pond Inlet on the northernmost part of Baffin Island across both Devon Island and Ellesmere Island to discover the Polar Inuit of north-western Greenland, who had been isolated for over a century.
To this day, the Polar Inuit of Greenland and the Canadian Inuit, especially from Pond Inlet, are closely related, and have family members on both sides. They share basically the same language, culture and way of life.
The migration had a profound effect on both the Greenlandic Polar Inuit, and those Inuit who migrated from Pond Inlet. The newcomers introduced important Inuit technology, such as the kayak, the bow and arrow, and fish spear.
Consequently, there has been a spiritual, social, cultural and linguistic bond between the Inuit of what is now the Canadian High Arctic, and the Polar Inuit of north-western Greenland, a bond that is very strong and very deep at the heart level, and includes family ties on both sides who speak the same heart language.
Nearly 2,000 years ago, the apostle Paul stood on Mars Hill, and boldly proclaimed that it is the God of heaven and earth who chooses the places where the nations (ethnos) live on all the face of the earth, and "He has determined the boundaries of their habitation" (Acts 17:26). A nation in the biblical sense of the word is not the same as a nation-state that has manmade, political boundaries defined by colonization and warfare. A nation is an ethnos, an ethnicity, or a people group who share a common language, culture and way of life. The boundaries for these nations (ethnicities) goes back to the Tower of Babel when God scattered the nations and set boundaries according to language. Genesis 11:8, 9; Deuteronomy 32:7, 8; Psalm 74:17; Proverbs 22:28; 23:10,11.
Even though the Inuit of present-day Qaanaaq, Greenland, and Grise Fiord, Nunavut, share the same culture and language, and are just over one hour's flying time apart, yet because of the political boundaries that man has erected, the only scheduled flights for these families to stay in physical contact would require one to fly from Grise Fiord to Resolute with Ken Borek Air, then from Resolute to Iqaluit and from Iqaluit to Ottawa with First Air, from Ottawa through Montreal to Copenhagen, Denmark, with Air Canada, and then from Copenhagen to Nuuk, Greenland, and from there north to Qaanaaq, Greenland, on a Danish Airline. This is about a four-day journey at a cost of mega thousands of dollars.
How did these political boundaries come to be established? Between 1904 and 1911, Captain Joseph E. Bernier did more than any other person to colonize, and to solidify Canada's claim to the Arctic islands.
The Canadian government even produced a special postage stamp in his honor, and named Bernier Bay on the north end of Baffin Island in his honor as well.
Captain Bernier extended the surveillance of the CGS Arctic ship into the North Baffin region by 1906.
Here he is formally taking possssion of Bylot Island, just north of Pond Inlet, in North Baffin, raising the Canadian flag (which was then the Canadian Red Ensign) at a ceremony at Canada Point in August, 1906.
Here, Captain Bernier is claiming all of Baffin Island for the Dominion of Canada in the presence of Inuit and officers during a ceremony on November 9, 1906. At the time, of course, the Inuit travelled in clans, and had no collective voice to speak about their values, so really had no voice in these decisions pertaining to Canada's claim to sovereignty over the land in the far North.
By 1923, the Canadian government tried to further extend its sovereignty over the High Arctic by holding its first criminal trial in the far north based on the British system of justice. The court case was held at the RCMP detachment in Pond Inlet, pictured above. An Inuit leader by the name of Nuqallaq was charged with murder for in self-defence killing an independent trader who was extremely abusive and mentally unstable. Nuqallaq was found guilty by the all-white jury who had little understanding of Inuit justice, language or cultural values, and was sentenced to 10 years in Stoney Mountain Penitentiary. After only two years, Nuqallaq died of tuberculosis that he picked up while in prison.
Here Judge Rivet, on the far left, is explaining the outcome of the trial, and the advantages of Canadian citizenship to the Inuit.
The Canadian government established RCMP posts at Pond Inlet (on northern Baffin Island) and at Craig Harper (on Ellesmere Island) in the year 1922. These posts were established for political purposes. In the early 1900s, the only people to venture that far north were a handful of explorers, the Canadian Inuit from North Baffin and the Polar Inuit from north-west Greenland. Since the Polar Inuit continued to treat Ellesmere Island as a hunting ground without regard to Canadian sovereignty claims, the need was seen for a greater presence in the region.By August of 1953, the Canadian government sought to further legitimize its claim to the High Arctic region, including such Arctic islands as Cornwallis Island, Devon Island and Ellesmere Island, by establishing a High Arctic Relocation policy. Through this policy, they were able to convince some 35 Inuit from Inukjuaq, Nunavik (northern Quebec), to relocate to Resolute Bay on Cornwallis Island and Grise Fiord on Ellesmere Island. Today, these are Canada's two most northern communities.
There is little doubt that the Canadian government's goal was to not only establish a Canadian presence on those northernmost islands, but a Canadian presence that would keep the Greenlanders away, and establish Canadian sovereignty up there. Yet remember that these Greenlandic Inuit had family ties to the Baffin Island Inuit in a way that transcended Canadian-Greenlandic political borders.
The Inuit from Nunavik were only convinced to relocate based on the understanding that there would be plenty of game, that the group would be kept together, and that they could return home after two years if they so desired.
Only after the C. D. Howe ship, which carried the relocatees, was past Pond Inlet (where they had picked up a few more relocatees) did they inform the group that they would be split up. Some of them were dropped off right here, on the side of this mountain, near present-day Grise Fiord, where for two years they lived on this land-locked site in tents. They felt like aliens in a strange land, not knowing where the animals were, or even fresh water. Among those dropped off was Larry Audlaluk, who was only three years of age in 1953.
Within eight months of being dropped off here, Larry Audlaluk's father Isi died of a broken heart, sighing with his dying breath that if he had know what they were getting into, he would never have agreed to this relocation.
Here, in 2005, some 51 years later, Larry Audlaluk and his son stand at the site of their father Isi's grave, which is right on the mountainside where their family was originally dropped off.
This is Larry Audlaluk when he was five years old, standing outside of his family's new dwelling, which by now had become a sod house covered with furs. Larry's mother spent much of her time looking for lumps of earth with which they could build this sod house after they moved a few kilometers to a new location in 1955.
Larry's dear mother lived pretty much out of a box over the next few years, always moving to a new location a few kilometers away after a previous location proved inadequate. Some times the ship failed to get through with supplies, and they had to survive for long periods of time on seal and walrus, two very strong forms of meat, and had to find a way to extract fresh water from salt water.
In the meantime, the Greenlandic Inuit (wearing polar bear pants) whom the Canadian Inuit were supposed to push out of Ellesmere Island, were actually more helpful to the High Arctic relocatees than even the Canadian government. They showed them where the fresh water lakes and animals were located. The man with the black pants (second from right) is Larry Audlaluk's brother-in-law, who also ended up dying prematurely.
The rest of the High Arctic Relocatees back in 1953 were dropped off at this exact spot near present-day Resolute Bay. Here are three of the original relocatees still living in Resolute Bay--Louisa Gillespie, Allie Salluviniq (Louisa's brother), and Simeonie Amagoalik (who was 19 years at the time of the relocation, and is the oldest living relocatee).
These people, too, felt like exiles, and lived under very difficult and harsh conditions, especially for the first two years at Resolute Bay. This picture was taken of their camp in 1953. Since there was a Canadian army base nearby, these Inuit survived by scavenging food from the army dump on occasions, but their emotional pain was aggravated when they learned that they could not return to their families in northern Quebec after two years, as was originally promised.
So over time, with Canadian Inuit now living in Resolute Bay and Grise Fiord, and with RCMP posts established in Pond Inlet in North Baffin and in Craig Harbour (pictured above) on Ellesmere Island, the presence of the Greenlandic Inuit did diminish in places like Ellesmere Island, although some ongoing contact was maintained for many years. However, the Greenlandic Inuit did tend to settle near Qaanaaq, presently a community of some 650 people, and to Sioraupaluk, an unincorporated settlement of about 60 people that is some 40 miles still further north. During the same year (1953) that the Canadian Inuit were relocated, the Qaanaaq Inuit were also relocated from Thule, which was near a U. S. Air Force base, some 40 miles further north to present-day Qaanaaq. They were given no choice, and were given only three days to make the move or their houses would have been bull dozed.
However, there was still some ongoing connection between the Inuit of Qaanaaq, Greenland, and Grise Fiord, Nunavut, as they could go back and forth between Ellsmere Island and Greenland by dogsled in winter without a Passport from either side. Larry Audlaluk writes that "I had been involved with exchanges every year since 1973 to 1990 without fail."
However, 911 changed all of that. Concern that international terrorists may want to get into North America through the Canadian Arctic has led to a rigid insistence that even the original peoples of the land now need a Passport to travel between remote communities like Qaanaaq, Greenland, and Grise Fiord, Nunavut. This is a huge challenge for Inuit who are distant geographically and culturally from government offices, not to mention the language barrier.
This, together with the melting ice in the Baffin Bay, has made it impossible to travel back and forth by dogsled any longer. The only option in staying physically connected is to charter an aircraft (unless one takes the round trip through southern Canada and Europe at huge time and expense).
Air Charter expenses are very high, along with significant landing fees imposed by the Danish and Canadian governments on all aircraft. There is a scheduled Kenn Borek flight from Resolute to Grise Fiord every Thursday and Saturday, but from Grise Fiord on to Qaanaaq, Greenland, one must Charter, with costs of nearly $18,000.00 for the return flight, even though the flight from Grise Fiord to Qaanaq is only about 1 1/4 hours.
Meanwhile, Canadian sovereignty is still not fully recognized between the Canadian and Danish governments in the area between Ellesmere Island and north-western Greenland. A tiny island known as Hans Island is still under dispute to this day. Bare and uninhabited, Hans Island is very hard to find on a map, and yet this small island is much in demand--so much so that Canada and Denmark have both staked their claim to it with flags and warships.
Here, the Danish sailors are raising their flag on Hans Island in 2002. It is estimated that the Arctic has as much as 25% of the world's undiscovered oil and gas. There is also a potential for minerals and diamonds. All this has pushed governments and businesses to scramble for sovereignty over these priceless seas and waterways.
Significantly, some of these very communities like Pond Inlet and Resolute Bay are right along the North West Passage, which is also still under dispute as to Canadian claims to sovereignty. The Americans, for example, hotly insist that the North West Passage is neutral, not a Canadian water way, and that security for vessels that go through it are to be under international, not Canadian surveillance.
As the North West Passage becomes increasingly navigable, especially during the summer months, Canadian claims to sovereignty will come under increasing challenge from nations who do not want to see it come under the control of one nation-state that can unfairly discriminate. The Europeans will want to increasingly use this water way, as it shortens the journey from Europe to parts of Asia by some 4,000 kilometers if they go this route, rather than through the Panama Canal.
All of this is in addition to the Russian claims to the Canadian and Danish High Arctic. On August 2, 2007, the Russians planted their flag 4,200 meters below the seabed at the North Pole. The rust-proof titanium metal flag was planted by explorers travelling in two mini-submarines. The Mir-I (pictured above) is one of two Russian craft that dived to the Arctic floor at the North Pole.
In 2004, Russian President Vladimir Putin called the sovereignty issue "a serious competitive battle" that "will unfold more and more fiercely."
After the Russians planted their flag on the seabed below the North Pole in 2007, the Hon. Peter MacKay, representing the Canadian government, responded, "This isn't the 15th century. You can't go around the world and just plant flags and say, 'We're claiming this territory.'" Try and tell that to Captain Bernier who planted the Canadian flag on Bylot Island in North Baffin in August of 1906, and soon thereafter, in November of 1906, claimed all of Baffin Island for the Dominion of Canada.
Ironically, it was Inuit like Ootah (Odak is the modern spelling) who was the main guide for the early North Pole Expeditions, such as those led by American explorer Robert Peary. It was Polar Inuit who knew this territory better than any of the explorers, and without their guidance, these discoveries would not even have been made.
A picture of Odak, the famous Inuit guide, is hanging in the Municipal Council Chambers in Qaanaaq, Greenland, today.
Yet this is a story that some of the High Arctic Relocatees believe will have a happy ending. On August 18, 2010, after many years of stonewalling, this surprising headline appeared in the CBC News: "Inuit Get Federal Apology for Forced Relocation."
On this date, the newly installed Minister of Indian Affairs and Northern Development for the Canadian government, the Hon. John Duncan, travelled to Inukjuaq, Nunavik (northern Quebec), to say to the High Arctic Relocatees and their families: "The Government of Canada deeply regrets the mistakes and broken promises of this dark chapter of our history, and apologizes for the High Arctic relocation having taken place." There was not a dry eye in the audience.
One week later, on August 25, 2010, Prime Minister Stephen Harper was in Resolute Bay, Nunavut, and had a private meeting with the High Arctic Relocatees to repeat the apology to them in person. Included in this photo, along with Prime Minister Stephen Harper, are Larry Audlaluk from Grise Fiord, and Allie Salluviniq and Louisa Gillespie from Resolute Bay, all original relocatees.
This newspaper story on the Prime Minister's 2010 Arctic Tour mentioned that in Resolute, Nunavut, the Prime Minister "met privately with Inuit elders to repeat the apology made earlier by Indian and Northern Affairs minister John Duncan for the federal government's forced relocation of eastern Arctic Inuit."
Here, on this very meaningful occasion in Resolute on August 25, 2010, one can see Prime Minister Stephen Harper along with some of the original relocatees--Allie and Susan Salluviniq, and Louisa Gillspie. Through their faith in a God who keeps His promises, they had found the grace to release forgiveness for the relocation even before the federal goverenment had apologized, knowing that God can use even our sufferings for a greater good.
These believing relocatees have no bitterness in them, and truly now believe that what once seemed like a curse can be transformed into a blessing as they fill this part of the earth with God's Presence and forgiveness. Here, Allie and Susan Salluviniq can be seen with the Hon. Leona Aglukaqq, the Minister of Health for the federal government, and the first Inuk federal Cabinet Minister. She was also in Resolute with the Prime Minister on August 25, 2010.
However, there was still some ongoing connection between the Inuit of Qaanaaq, Greenland, and Grise Fiord, Nunavut, as they could go back and forth between Ellsmere Island and Greenland by dogsled in winter without a Passport from either side. Larry Audlaluk writes that "I had been involved with exchanges every year since 1973 to 1990 without fail."
However, 911 changed all of that. Concern that international terrorists may want to get into North America through the Canadian Arctic has led to a rigid insistence that even the original peoples of the land now need a Passport to travel between remote communities like Qaanaaq, Greenland, and Grise Fiord, Nunavut. This is a huge challenge for Inuit who are distant geographically and culturally from government offices, not to mention the language barrier.
This, together with the melting ice in the Baffin Bay, has made it impossible to travel back and forth by dogsled any longer. The only option in staying physically connected is to charter an aircraft (unless one takes the round trip through southern Canada and Europe at huge time and expense).
Air Charter expenses are very high, along with significant landing fees imposed by the Danish and Canadian governments on all aircraft. There is a scheduled Kenn Borek flight from Resolute to Grise Fiord every Thursday and Saturday, but from Grise Fiord on to Qaanaaq, Greenland, one must Charter, with costs of nearly $18,000.00 for the return flight, even though the flight from Grise Fiord to Qaanaq is only about 1 1/4 hours.
Meanwhile, Canadian sovereignty is still not fully recognized between the Canadian and Danish governments in the area between Ellesmere Island and north-western Greenland. A tiny island known as Hans Island is still under dispute to this day. Bare and uninhabited, Hans Island is very hard to find on a map, and yet this small island is much in demand--so much so that Canada and Denmark have both staked their claim to it with flags and warships.
Here, the Danish sailors are raising their flag on Hans Island in 2002. It is estimated that the Arctic has as much as 25% of the world's undiscovered oil and gas. There is also a potential for minerals and diamonds. All this has pushed governments and businesses to scramble for sovereignty over these priceless seas and waterways.
Significantly, some of these very communities like Pond Inlet and Resolute Bay are right along the North West Passage, which is also still under dispute as to Canadian claims to sovereignty. The Americans, for example, hotly insist that the North West Passage is neutral, not a Canadian water way, and that security for vessels that go through it are to be under international, not Canadian surveillance.
As the North West Passage becomes increasingly navigable, especially during the summer months, Canadian claims to sovereignty will come under increasing challenge from nations who do not want to see it come under the control of one nation-state that can unfairly discriminate. The Europeans will want to increasingly use this water way, as it shortens the journey from Europe to parts of Asia by some 4,000 kilometers if they go this route, rather than through the Panama Canal.
All of this is in addition to the Russian claims to the Canadian and Danish High Arctic. On August 2, 2007, the Russians planted their flag 4,200 meters below the seabed at the North Pole. The rust-proof titanium metal flag was planted by explorers travelling in two mini-submarines. The Mir-I (pictured above) is one of two Russian craft that dived to the Arctic floor at the North Pole.
In 2004, Russian President Vladimir Putin called the sovereignty issue "a serious competitive battle" that "will unfold more and more fiercely."
After the Russians planted their flag on the seabed below the North Pole in 2007, the Hon. Peter MacKay, representing the Canadian government, responded, "This isn't the 15th century. You can't go around the world and just plant flags and say, 'We're claiming this territory.'" Try and tell that to Captain Bernier who planted the Canadian flag on Bylot Island in North Baffin in August of 1906, and soon thereafter, in November of 1906, claimed all of Baffin Island for the Dominion of Canada.
Yet this is a story that some of the High Arctic Relocatees believe will have a happy ending. On August 18, 2010, after many years of stonewalling, this surprising headline appeared in the CBC News: "Inuit Get Federal Apology for Forced Relocation."
On this date, the newly installed Minister of Indian Affairs and Northern Development for the Canadian government, the Hon. John Duncan, travelled to Inukjuaq, Nunavik (northern Quebec), to say to the High Arctic Relocatees and their families: "The Government of Canada deeply regrets the mistakes and broken promises of this dark chapter of our history, and apologizes for the High Arctic relocation having taken place." There was not a dry eye in the audience.
This newspaper story on the Prime Minister's 2010 Arctic Tour mentioned that in Resolute, Nunavut, the Prime Minister "met privately with Inuit elders to repeat the apology made earlier by Indian and Northern Affairs minister John Duncan for the federal government's forced relocation of eastern Arctic Inuit."Please proceed to part 2 for "the rest of the story!"
0 comments






















Roger and Marge Armbruster are bridge-builders and advocates of reconciliation and social justice between people groups and cultures. They both minister cross-culturally -- Marge by teaching English to new immigrants in rural southern Manitoba, and Roger by helping to build relationships between various indigenous groups who understand the connection that there is between people and land, with a special focus on the Inuit of Canada's North.
